If you are developing a mushroom product for the European market, one of the first decisions you need to make is not the species, the dose, or the packaging. It is whether your product is a food supplement or a food product.
This isn’t a branding choice; it is a regulatory classification that determines which rules apply to your labelling, ingredients, claims, and — in some cases — whether you are allowed to sell the product at all.
We work with brands across both categories. This article explains the distinction, why it matters specifically for mushroom extracts, and what you need to consider before committing to a product format.
The legal distinction
In the EU, there is no legal definition of “functional food.” The term is widely used in marketing, but it does not exist in European food law. What does exist is a clear regulatory line between two categories:
Directive 2002/46/EC governs food supplements. They are concentrated sources of nutrients or other substances with a nutritional or physiological effect, sold in dose form (capsules, tablets, sachets, drops). They carry mandatory warnings: “Food supplements are not a substitute for a varied diet,” “Do not exceed the recommended daily portion,” and “Keep out of reach of young children.”
Food products — including beverages, instant drink mixes, coffee blends, snack bars, and anything else consumed as food rather than taken as a dose — fall under the general food law framework: Regulation (EC) No 178/2002, Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 (food information), and any applicable product-specific rules.
Both categories are subject to the same health claims rules under Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006. Neither can make unauthorised health claims about mushroom ingredients.
Why the distinction matters for mushroom extracts
For most food ingredients, the classification question is straightforward. For mushroom extracts, it is not — because the Novel Food Regulation (EU 2015/2283) treats the same extract differently depending on which category it goes into.
The EU Novel Food Catalogue records the history of use for each ingredient before 15 May 1997. An ingredient that has a documented history of use as a food supplement may not have the same history of use as a food product, and vice versa. The assessment depends on the species, the part used, the extraction method, and the intended use category.
Here is where this becomes practical:
Lion’s Mane (Hericium erinaceus) — fruiting body hot-water extract has established use as a food and as a food supplement. It can go into a coffee blend or a capsule.
Reishi (Ganoderma lucidum) — fruiting body hot-water extract has established use. A dual extract (hot water and ethanol) is a different process and may be assessed differently. Most brands use dual-extracted Reishi in supplement capsules; using it in a food beverage requires careful assessment.
Cordyceps CS-4 (Samsoniella hepiali) — liquid-cultured mycelium with documented use in food supplements. Its use as an ingredient in a food product (such as a coffee or a ready-to-drink beverage) is not covered by the same assessment. Brands developing a Cordyceps coffee need to consider this.
Chaga (Inonotus obliquus) — not classified as a noa vel food. It can be used in food and in supplements. However, the documentation supporting its use is primarily in the supplement category, so brands using it in a food product should maintain their own regulatory file.
Tremella, Maitake, Shiitake — all have long histories of use as food in Asia and as food ingredients in Europe. These are the least problematic species for food-category products.
The key point: the novel food position is not a property of the mushroom. It is a property of the mushroom, processed in a specific way and used in a specific product category. Change the category, and you may change the regulatory position.
Labelling: different rules, different obligations
The product classification determines what must appear on your label.
A food supplement sold in the EU must carry, at a minimum:
- The words “food supplement” (or the equivalent in the language of the member state)
- The name of each ingredient, including the species and the part used
- The recommended daily portion, stated clearly
- A warning not to exceed the recommended daily portion
- A statement that food supplements are not a substitute for a varied diet
- A statement to keep out of reach of young children
- A warning to consult a doctor if pregnant, breastfeeding, or taking medication
- The name and address of the food business operator
- The net quantity
- The batch number and best-before date
A food product (such as a mushroom coffee blend) follows the general food information rules under Regulation 1169/2011, which include:
- A complete ingredient list in descending order of weight
- Allergen declarations (in bold or otherwise emphasised)
- Net quantity, best-before date, storage conditions
- Nutritional declaration (energy, fat, saturates, carbohydrate, sugars, protein, salt)
- The name and address of the food business operator
- Country of origin where required
The nutritional declaration is mandatory for food products but not for food supplements (which declare the active substance content instead). If you are developing a shroom coffee, you will need a full nutritional analysis of the finished blend —not just the extract specifications.
Health claims: same rules for both
Whether your product is a food supplement or a food product, the same health claims regulation applies. Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006 governs all nutrition and health claims made on food, including supplements.
There is currently no authorised health claim for any mushroom or mushroom constituent in the EU. This means:
- You cannot say your product supports immunity, cognition, focus, energy, stress, sleep, or any other physiological function
- You cannot use implied claims such as “nootropic,” “adaptogen,” “brain health,” or “feel the difference”
- You cannot use customer testimonials that contain health claims (a testimonial published by the company is the company’s statement)
- These rules apply to your label, your website, your social media, your advertising, and your packaging
If your product contains an ingredient that does carry an authorised claim (for example, magnesium, which has authorised claims relating to normal psychological function), you may use that specific authorised wording. But you cannot extend that claim to cover the mushroom ingredients in the same product.
Practical considerations for brands
If you are deciding between launching a supplement or a food product, here are the factors to weigh:
Choose a food supplement format if:
- You want to use dual-extracted (ethanol) mushroom extracts, which have a clearer regulatory position in the supplement category
- You want to use Cordyceps CS-4, which has documented supplement use but an uncertain position in food
- You are targeting a market that expects capsules, tablets, or powder sachets with dosing instructions
- You want to make an authorised health claim about a non-mushroom ingredient (such as a vitamin or mineral) alongside your mushroom extract
Choose a food product format if:
- You are developing a mushroom coffee, a beverage, a snack bar, or any product consumed as food
- You want to use species with strong food-use history (Lion’s Mane, Tremella, Maitake, Shiitake)
- You are targeting consumers who do not think of themselves as supplement users
- You want broader retail distribution (coffee shelves, not supplement aisles)
In either case, you are the food business operator (FBO) responsible for the product. You are responsible for ensuring every ingredient is permitted for sale in your product category and target market. Your supplier provides the raw material documentation; you make the regulatory decision.
What we supply
We provide mushroom extracts for both categories. Our hot-water extracts and double-filtered extracts are used in food supplements, coffee blends, beverage formulations, and custom products across the EU and UK.
For every extract we supply, we provide a technical data sheet, a batch-specific Certificate of Analysis from an ISO/IEC 17025-accredited laboratory, and the documentation you need for your compliance file. We can advise on the best extraction type and species for your product format, and we work with food law consultants who can review your specific formulation.
If you are developing a mushroom product and are unsure about the classification, get in touch. The earlier you get this right, the less it costs to fix later.
Mycogenius B.V., trading as FunctionalMushrooms.eu, is a B2B mushroom extract supplier based in Amsterdam, the Netherlands. We supply independently tested extracts to supplement brands, beverage formulators, and private-label partners across Europe.

